France’s Debt Has Come Due and The Streets are Paying the Price
The protests of 17 October are the visible end of a fifty-year habit, a three-year political breakdown and a budget that made the young generation pay for the debt of their ancestors. Pakistan should recognise the pattern.

What happens when a nation that has taught the world to take to streets finds that this time, its streets no longer listen? One of the severest civil unrests in France. An estimated 550,000 people marched across France over the weekend of 17 October. Most of them marched peacefully however, by nightfall, the police had used severe measures to control the aggressive mob, shops had been looted, businesses set fire to, and the historic town hall in Limoges had largely burned down. Over a thousand people were arrested in what the government described as “escalation in violence”. Watching the images, it may seem a sudden explosion. It was nothing of the kind. France’s crisis has been building quietly for decades, and quite loudly for the past three years.
France’s Debt Crisis Did Not Begin on the Streets
Why did this march start? Mostly students, working class and the ‘yellow vests’ marched against the rising cost of living that climbed beyond reach with the fuel prices pushed ever higher by a war fought far from French soil. Their grievance was, by an honest measure, a legitimate one. What started as a language of reason had turned to the language of fire. Vehicles in the street were reduced to blackened shells, shops stripped bare and the base of Marianne herself at Place de la République prised apart. In Limoges, a 19th century City Hall was set on fire. It is hard not to feel that the protestors perhaps betrayed the very people they claimed to march beside because the violence undermined the cause. President Macron promised that the guilty would pay which rings with its own kind of deafness as though the problem was lack of order and not the extreme tax-stricken people. The government’s response appeared to be more on ‘order’ than addressing the underlying causes. Because punishment may restore calm, but the trust cannot be forced. Feverish arrest will only clear the boulevards; they will not be able to root out the resentment.
The 2027 budget, presented on 1 October, seeks about €54 billion in savings and tax measures to bring the deficit from 5.4% to 5% of GDP. It freezes most spending in cash terms, which means real cuts once inflation is counted, freezes civil servants’ basic pay scale for a fourth consecutive year, and trims healthcare and pensions. But the spark came from classrooms. In September, students in the working-class suburbs north of Paris began protesting overcrowded classes, crumbling buildings and shortage of teaching staff. Their demands were modest: decent schools and enough teachers. Yet France spends more than the EU average on education, and much of that budget goes on pensions for retired teachers. The students were, in effect, protesting the bill for a system their grandparents built before they were born.
Their movement merged with public sector strikes, the remnants of the 2025 “Bloquons tout” campaign, ‘yellow vest’ veterans angry about fuel prices and the cost of living, and those opposed to rising defence spending. Reports of heavy-handed policing, including children seriously injured by police munitions, deepened the anger. The demand for a better education system became a referendum on who pays for France’s debt.
France’s Crisis is not an Accident
France has not balanced a budget since 1974. For half a century, it spent more than it collected and borrowed the difference, cushioned by a single currency that kept its borrowing costs close to Germany’s. Public debt stood just under 100% of GDP before the pandemic. Then came Emmanuel Macron’s “whatever it costs” response to Covid-19, followed by an energy price shield that capped household bills after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Each decision was reasonable at the time but together, along with the tax cuts that were never paid for, they piled up into a serious problem. They left the state with debt that now stands at around €3.596 trillion, or 119% of GDP, the highest ratio since the aftermath of the Second World War.
When Governments Borrow the Future, the Young Pay the Bill
Is debt, on its own, enough to bring a nation to its knees? Not quite. Japan carries far more of it, and its streets remain calm. The danger, however, lies in who holds it and what it costs. More than half of France’s debt is held by foreign investors, and France borrows in a currency it does not control. When those investors grow nervous, and France cannot print its own currency to calm them. This month, France’s ten-year borrowing costs touched their highest level since 2002, and for a time, the market charged France more to borrow than Italy or Greece. Interest payments are expected to reach about €91 billion next year, money that cannot be spent on schools, hospitals or wages.
How Politics Turned a Problem into a Crisis
The warning signs had been flashing for years; it was politics that finally set them alight. In June 2024, after a heavy defeat in the European elections, Macron dissolved the National Assembly. The snap election produced a parliament split into three camps, none strong enough to govern. Since then, budgets have become the weapon by which governments fall. Michel Barnier’s government was toppled in December 2024, the first successful no-confidence vote since 1962, after he forced through a social security budget without a vote. His successor, François Bayrou, proposed €44 billion in savings for 2026, including scrapping two public holidays and freezing pensions, and lost a confidence vote in September 2025. Then, Sébastien Lecornu replaced him, resigned within weeks, and was reappointed, surviving only after suspending Macron’s own flagship pension reform. In both 2025 and 2026, France relied on emergency laws to keep the state funded without an approved budget. Credit agencies responded with downgrades. Investors noticed that France kept missing its own deficit targets.
In Paris, those in power were too busy keeping their own seats warm to notice that the country was slowly running cold. If France wishes to avoid another such outburst, it must learn to hear the difference between a looter and a citizen who simply cannot afford to live. And if the government answers each strike with handcuffs, it should not be surprised when the next protest begins already burning.
What is Next for France
The immediate test is parliamentary. The revenue section of the budget faces a vote this week, and the full bill in mid-November. If it fails, borrowing costs could climb further. Some analysts have openly raised the possibility that France might one day need outside help, though the European Central Bank’s safety net comes with conditions France has repeatedly struggled to meet.
The deeper test is political. A presidential election is due in spring 2027, and the far right, led by Marine Le Pen, has been leading the polls, with the far left close behind. Neither offers fiscal restraint. Le Pen has promised to lower the retirement age, and the far left proposes cancelling central bank holdings of French debt. Le Pen has called the protesters’ grievances “legitimate” while blaming the left for exploiting them, a framing that may redirect economic anger towards immigration. Whoever wins may still lack a majority in parliament. The risk is a cycle in which austerity fuels anger, anger then fuels the extremes, and the extremes make markets more nervous still.
France’s Crisis Is a Warning Pakistan Cannot Afford to Ignore
Pakistan’s situation differs in important ways. Its debt is lower, around 70% of GDP, but far more expensive. Debt servicing consumes roughly half of all federal revenue, and much of the borrowing is in foreign currency. Pakistan has entered more than twenty IMF programmes, and its current $7 billion facility ties every disbursement to tax rises and energy price reforms that land directly on households.
Yet the pattern is familiar. Pakistan knows this story well: old loans eating away at today’s needs, relief promised but never funded, and the heaviest burden always landing on students, workers and families who struggle to pay their electricity bills.
France’s lesson is that behind every debt crisis, under all the figures and percentages, sits a simpler and more fragile thing: whether people still trust those who govern them, whether citizens believe the sacrifice is shared, and whether lenders believe the politics can hold. When both breaks, the bill arrives on the streets. Pakistan, with far less room for error, cannot afford to learn that lesson the way France is learning it now.

Mahliqa Asmat
Editor, The Fourth Dawn
Mahliqa Asmat is a Glasgow-based writer trained in journalism, media and literature. She holds advanced degrees in Media & Communication and English Literature, and writes on power, framing, culture and the moving image. She is the founder of The Fourth Dawn and of S.C.R.I.P.T., a language-learning platform.
More about Mahliqa →